Here’s Why Your SEO Isn’t Working Or Failed To Increase Traffic

So you’re trying DIY SEO, or maybe you hired an SEO company or consultant to do SEO for your business. It’s been three months, and your traffic leads and sales have not increased. You start to wonder why your SEO isn’t working. maybe SEO doesn’t work for your business, or you think you’ve failed.

As the frustration mounts, a ton of questions begin to run through your head, “how long should SEO take?” “Should I hire someone instead of trying it myself?” “Did I hire the wrong SEO company?”.

We, as SEOs, may not know all the reasons a website ranks within Google, but through testing, we have found some solid correlations for why sites don’t rank. This correlation gives us high-level insight into how Google Search works and how Google ranks websites both nationally and in their local SEO results.

How Does Google Rank Websites

Below, you will find some factors that contribute to how Google Search works,  how Google indexes and ranks websites, and variables the Googlebot Persona analyzes when determining which websites should have lower rankings or removed websites from its search results entirely.

At a very high level, most websites don’t rank because of a lack of authority, trust, or relevancy compared to other websites targeting the same topics.

Note that because each of these factors doesn’t exist in a vacuum, your website may suffer from any number of these things.

Before taking drastic measures or implementing risky and desperate SEO strategies, read over this list of possible reasons why your SEO is not working or may have failed.

Your Website Design Experience

Does your website delight users and look great on all devices? Was SEO included throughout the design and development process? Here are a few things to check:

  • Was there a strategy outlined for your website design?
  • Was a website information architecture strategy built and implemented?
  • Was a content strategy created, and was the on-site SEO optimization basics completed?
  • Was there a transition plan developed and implemented?

Your Website Speed

Does site speed affect your SEO rankings? Yes, site speed impacts rankings but carries less weight than key ranking factors such as valuable content, relevance, authority links, etc.

With mobile browsing becoming a more significant part of how users find and interact with your website, that’s no longer accurate. As a result, speed is becoming more of an SEO ranking factor.

Does site speed affect your conversion rate? Research has found that 47% of your target audience expects your website to load in under two seconds.

With the vast number of site speed tools, including Pingdom or Google’s own PageSpeed Tool, there are no excuses why a website’s speed should not be optimized for SEO and users.

Your Content Has Gaps

We often talk with clients who want to drive traffic from Google for specific keywords and topics. However, when we do a fundamental gap analysis on their website, they have little-to-no content for many of the keywords they want to target.

If you’re missing content, remember that you can’t rank for keywords and topics without content proving to Google that you should.

You Created Bad Content

This checklist item is one of the top 3 reasons your SEO is not working. Google uses machine learning more frequently in their Panda and primary algorithm to identify high-value content and rank it within their organic search results.

Don’t expect to rank if you’ve paid someone to create generic 500-word articles for your website. Instead, be prepared to invest in high-value content – articles, videos, and infographics.

One of the strategies we help clients with is identifying content that is not performing and building a strategy to fix it – commonly known as a ROT analysis.

Content Is Not Optimized

Content strategy is probably the simplest of the concerns, as it speaks to basic search engine optimization. Some things to check are:

  • Is the target keyword in the title tag?
  • Is the target keyword in the H1 tag?
  • Is the target keyword used consistently in the primary content area of the webpage?
  • For example, is the target keyword used in the Alt text of images in the immediate content area of the webpage?
  • Does the content include H2 tags (subtopics of the H1 tag) that include additional related keywords

Over-optimized Content

On the flip side of content that is not optimized is that which is over-optimized. Google has said that adding a keyword a few times will help. Still, there is a point at which adding the same keyword one more time negatively affects rankings, user experience, and readability.

I would suggest reading your content aloud, and if it does not read in the same way you would normally speak, you have probably over-optimized the content to the point of losing value.

Content is Duplicated

Duplicate content is still a problem that most websites encounter. For example, some content can cause search engines to get confused as to which piece of content is the primary version, or it can cause users to link to multiple versions of the same amount of content, thus causing the value of those links to become fragmented.

Internal Duplication happens when the same piece of primary content is on multiple URLs within the same website.

External Duplication can occur when the same content is placed on multiple websites. Critical times when this happens:

  • Website is scraped
  • Website owners try to manipulate Google’s desire to show a diversity of websites in the top 10 results by putting the same content on multiple websites.
  • Websites that operate under distribution or reseller models put the same product description across all their reseller’s websites, causing Google to filter many of them from their search results.

Content Can’t Be Found or is Blocked

This speaks to how Google finds and indexes website content by crawling links. In contrast, this is a less frequent concern; we still see it happening. Either a website is designed in a way that limits Google’s ability to crawl it and find the content, or worse case, a website blocks (usually by forgetting to remove the noindex tags from the header or the disallow command from the robots.txt file when going from a staging server to production server) Google from crawling their website altogether.

You’re Lacking Inbound Links

Is link building dead? Yes and no. Earning high-value links is still a primary ranking factor within Google’s algorithm, but Google has been tweaking the links they will allow to pass the ranking value (link juice) to your website. So, link building at its core is not dead, but how you earn links has evolved considerably over the years.

Links are still a significant variable in Google’s algorithm. Therefore, a website with insufficient high-value links can be deemed not valuable enough to rank in Google.

Now, don’t think you can go out and buy links or do things too quickly to gain links. Link building is about creating great website design experiences and content that naturally earns links. So if you don’t have enough connections to help Google see your website as authoritative, trustworthy, and relevant enough to rank, start creating some excellent content and market that content to earn the links that Google wants to value.

So, if your content lacks those that Google wants to reward, your SEO will not work.

Over-optimized Links

On the flip side of your website not having enough links, is it having links and a link graph that are over-optimized and look manipulative? To fight link spam and devalue websites participating in link manipulation, Google has released numerous iterations of the Penguin update and their recent Payday Loan Update. There are two types of over-optimized links:

Internal links: These are the links in your navigation, footer, sidebar, or any contextual link that helps a user navigate your website.

You can usually tell a group of navigational links is spammy if the anchor text goes beyond what an average user would need to know to determine what the page being linked to is actually about.

Most of the time, this type of internal link spam happens in the sidebar or footer of a website, where large blocks of links can be placed that have little effect on the primary user experience of the page.

External links: Most of the time, when we think of over-optimized external links, we think of exact match anchor text links that have been bought (not earned). But there are other ways this mass creation of spammy links can occur.

This includes:

  • Press Release Syndication
  • Article Syndication
  • Article Scraping
  • Article Spinning

Your Information Architecture Is Confusing

As mentioned above, Google wants to reward great experiences and website designs. A primary part of any great design is how the information is organized and the strategic approach to building the website’s taxonomy – also known as information architecture.

So ask yourself, “Is my website’s information architecture aligned with how my users think about my products or services and optimized for Google’s crawlers? If it’s not, your SEO could fail to earn rankings.

You Built Bad Links

This checklist item is probably one of the top 3 reasons your SEO is not working. Link building (link earning) should not be an SEO strategy outsourced to the lowest bidder.

If your link-building is not centered around creating great content and marketing it to earn links, you’re doing it wrong.

If you hired your link-building company based on price or a defined number of links per month, you could be setting yourself up for failure or permanently destroying your rankings and SEO.

You Thought You Could Get Away With It

Don’t be an idiot. You’re not smarter than Google engineers. You may get away with a tactic for a while, but you will get caught if you try to implement manipulative or high-risk SEO tactics.

Get it out of your mind that you, an SEO, or any agency can trick or manipulate Google into ranking your website. SEO is a long-term strategy and does not include misleading or using any bot or user.

You Hired Your SEO Company Based Primarily On Price

Do you think so little of your company that you would hand it over to someone who spams and tarnishes your brand name with low-value comment spam and poorly written articles? Stop searching for cheap SEO companies or choosing a company to market your business based on the lowest price.

Instead, partner with a company that will help you create a holistic SEO and website experience that your users will love. When choosing your digital agency to help you do SEO, consider building long-term value, creating great experiences, building your brand, and publishing great content.

The SEO agency or consulting team that will give you the best chance of succeeding with your SEO will probably not be the cheapest, but they will be worth it.

You’re Being Out-Marketed By Your Competition

This might be one of the most straightforward answers, yet one that most people don’t think about. First, businesses must understand that websites don’t operate in a vacuum. All websites are in flux, adding new products, content, and experiences.

Websites must evolve consistently, add new content, and create high-value experiences to compete with competitors already doing it.

Someone always tries to take your top position for a keyword your rank for today.

Negative SEO

This is a highly debated topic regarding the validity of its existence and the ability of a third party to influence your rankings negatively. This involves competitors or those with a vendetta against your website creating many exact-match links on low-quality websites to make it look like you were buying links or trying to be manipulative.

Google recently revised its official wording about negative SEO, saying, “There’s almost nothing a competitor can do to harm your ranking or have your site removed from our index” to “Google works hard to prevent other webmasters from being able to harm your ranking or have your site removed from our index.”

Some marketing experts think that because the Google webspam team has become more aggressive in controlling link building they believe is spam or manipulative, it is now easier to execute negative SEO attacks.

Site Was Hacked

There are many ways you may discover your website has been hacked. The most obvious is when the hacker has defaced your website.

However, hackers often prefer that you don’t know about it because they want to use your site as long as possible to do their dirty work.

Signs that your website has been hacked:

  • Your website is defaced.
  • You receive a notice from Google or Bing in Webmaster Tools notifying you that your site has been compromised.
  • Your Firefox or Chrome web browser indicates that your site may be compromised.
  • You notice strange traffic in your weblogs, such as unexplained big spikes in traffic, especially from other countries.
  • You check your search query report in Google and find that you receive traffic for off-topic keywords.
  • If you go to your website, hit “control + A” (which highlights all the content on your website, even that which you can’t see), and you see links to other sites show up or hidden content on the page that you can’t see usually.